
Treating symptoms vs. the illness
Deal with the surface of a problem or dig down deep? Treat the symptoms or cure the underlying illness? Or do both? In terms of one’s health, hopefully treating an illness and its symptoms are related closely enough that it’s possible to do both at the same time. Improving violin intonation is similarly complicated.
All roads lead to intonation
I have had students who practice, play with a lot of skill on a good instrument but never seem to achieve a beautiful sound. It might not be readily obvious why the violin playing doesn’t sound very good. For these students, my approach is from the vantage point of intonation.
Tuning to the instrument
I do think it is important to help students play in tune at the note level especially if there is a technical issue going on with the student’s left hand or fingering. However, the help given is basically to alleviate anxiety about wrong sounding notes and won’t necessarily do anything to help improve the overall sound. It is much harder to teach students how to be in tune with their instrument. There may have to be tough conversations with students and parents in terms of prioritizing intonation work.
Violinist Linda Beers is the creator of the Inspiration for Violinists, a 50 card deck. Each card has a unique image and text inspiring musicianship, mindfulness and spirituality.